Mitolo G.A.M. McLaren Vale Shiraz 2004

Shay A

My bottle of choice for the WNH virtual tasting (@David L , @Shawn R , @Eric LaMasters , @Joe Lucca , @Mike R , @Bill Bender , @Carl Fischer ) with a theme of 10yrs or older, chosen by Eric. A beautiful bottle of aged Shiraz from a lovely producer. Double decanted in the event there was sediment but there was hardly any (cork was pristine as well). Where some Aussie Shiraz can come across boozy and out of sync, this is a great restrained example. Followed over a few hours and the aromatics didn’t change much...mostly raspberry fig, baking spices, tobacco and smoked meats accompanied by a touch of age. The palate was a reality check...totally youthful. Vibrant and juicy. Tart strawberries, rhubarb and black cherries. Fleshy. Gained some weight as it opened showing liqueur, boysenberries, licorice and overripe mixed dark fruits. Beautiful example of aged Aussie Shiraz. Not getting any better, but not falling off a cliff any time soon. Kudos to the man, myth and legend, Bill B.

Bill Bender

Round and ready. Tannins are no longer sharp and this is drinking very, very well.

Perry Riddle

Still a bit brazen and hot for my taste on its own. Maybe with a grilled ribeye?

Andrew Lampasone

Owner Wine Watch Selections

A great vintage for south Australia this is just starting to drink at its peak bravo Ben glaetzer

John Pavlovich

The best of the trio. Mature but very fresh, round and complex on the palate, a splendid bottle of wine. With many more years ahead of it.

Jeroen Koenen

Sweet sandalwood, prunes, teriyaki beef, roasted pecans. This wine has just started its descent. So drink it. ASAP.

Richard Sohn

Amazing freshness & intensity at 16+ years

Joseph Barsky

2004 Vintage. Sadly, badly corked.

Martin Sher

As you would expect: big unapologetic Shiraz. Huge dark fruit. I was in the mood - 2 hour decant and it finally started to hit its higher gears. Plenty of life left.

James Park

Spicy, prune, amarone like. Nice age and balance.