Jay Kline
Popped and poured; consumed over three days. The 2017 Musar “Hochar Pere et Fils” presents a deep garnet color with a near opaque core. Moderate staining of the tears. On the nose the wine is funky cherry accompanied by desiccated strawberry, leather, damp earth, espresso, baking chocolate, and some exotic spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannin and medium+ acid. Confirming the fruit characteristics and non-fruit characteristics whilst adding a licorice, prunes and a woody note reminiscent of a hollowed out log. I have to say…after some time (Day 3), it’s just the slightest bit mousy...showing some volatility too…but well within my acceptable range for it. Finishes long, lasting well over a minute. Savory. A tremendous wine with a very Old World (Ancient) sensibility. The best vintage of “Hochar” I have had to date? To my taste, yes.
Popped and poured; consumed over three days. The 2017 Musar “Hochar Pere et Fils” presents a deep garnet color with a near opaque core. Moderate staining of the tears. On the nose the wine is funky cherry accompanied by desiccated strawberry, leather, damp earth, espresso, baking chocolate, and some exotic spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannin and medium+ acid. Confirming the fruit characteristics and non-fruit characteristics whilst adding a licorice, prunes and a woody note reminiscent of a hollowed out log. I have to say…after some time (Day 3), it’s just the slightest bit mousy...showing some volatility too…but well within my acceptable range for it. Finishes long, lasting well over a minute. Savory. A tremendous wine with a very Old World (Ancient) sensibility. The best vintage of “Hochar” I have had to date? To my taste, yes.
9.3Aaron Tan
In stark contrast with the rather polished and fruity Margaret River Bordeaux blend, this was all rustic and savoury. Sure under that veneer of volatile acidity and strong leather aromas, lied some nervy black cherries with lovely cedar-spice and licorice, yet in typical Musar manner, most in the group found this difficult to drink. I believe it's the combination of grainy tannic structure plus VA-derived vinegar aromas and umeshu-like twang in this finish that threw most off. I, on the other hand, found it quite compelling.
In stark contrast with the rather polished and fruity Margaret River Bordeaux blend, this was all rustic and savoury. Sure under that veneer of volatile acidity and strong leather aromas, lied some nervy black cherries with lovely cedar-spice and licorice, yet in typical Musar manner, most in the group found this difficult to drink. I believe it's the combination of grainy tannic structure plus VA-derived vinegar aromas and umeshu-like twang in this finish that threw most off. I, on the other hand, found it quite compelling.
8.9Hetty Forsyth
Spicey notes of rosemary, thyme, clove with cherry and plum fruits.
Spicey notes of rosemary, thyme, clove with cherry and plum fruits.
8.8Marc Ouellette
I normally say “leave it to those Italians” but let me add in those Lebanese!! This 2017 blend is exquisite - starting with a luscious crimson garnet color followed by succulent aromas of cherries, dates, fig, and a hint of plum. Carefully aged this wine brings out flashes of spices of cinnamon and thyme. This wine emotes balanced tannins and a medium body! Salute!
I normally say “leave it to those Italians” but let me add in those Lebanese!! This 2017 blend is exquisite - starting with a luscious crimson garnet color followed by succulent aromas of cherries, dates, fig, and a hint of plum. Carefully aged this wine brings out flashes of spices of cinnamon and thyme. This wine emotes balanced tannins and a medium body! Salute!
9.6Ely Cohn
My first Musar Rouge outside of the Jeune line is a step up in complexity. It's the aromatic push of acetone and greasy fruit roll-up that hits the upper registers of my nose. I love that. And its the structure too. Young, textured with pulp, grip of an iron fist. A little bit abrasive but something that can work its way through in a few years. Flavors of cedar, pencil shavings, graphite, and iron rich bloody cherry juice. Worth stashing a few to see how this evolves.
My first Musar Rouge outside of the Jeune line is a step up in complexity. It's the aromatic push of acetone and greasy fruit roll-up that hits the upper registers of my nose. I love that. And its the structure too. Young, textured with pulp, grip of an iron fist. A little bit abrasive but something that can work its way through in a few years. Flavors of cedar, pencil shavings, graphite, and iron rich bloody cherry juice. Worth stashing a few to see how this evolves.
9.2Max Nomadic
Wonderful
Wonderful
9.7Albert Phelps
After a short time to open up, this wine has everything. Fruit, spice, full body. Delicious and smooth.
After a short time to open up, this wine has everything. Fruit, spice, full body. Delicious and smooth.
9.0Heather Rostker
Dinner at Lebanese Taverna calls for a nice Lebanese wine.
Dinner at Lebanese Taverna calls for a nice Lebanese wine.
8.7Panagis Vagenas
Always up for MUSAR!
Always up for MUSAR!
9.5Ronald Mitchell
Love the earthiness
Love the earthiness
8.6Location
WARNING: DRINKING DISTILLED SPIRITS, BEER, COOLERS, WINE AND OTHER ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES MAY INCREASE CANCER RISK, AND, DURING PREGNANCY, CAN CAUSE BIRTH DEFECTS.