The 2007 Barolo Ciabot Mentin is one of the greatest wines I have ever tasted at this address. Deep, sensual layers of fruit flow from the glass as this full-throttle, intense Barolo reveals its profound, breathtaking personality. The 2007 shows tons of Ginestra nuance, but with extra dimensions to the fruit that literally covers every nook and cranny of the palate. Tasting this next to the 2006 is quite a comparison, as both wines are fabulous. Readers who can should be sure to own bottles of both. A side-by-side comparison is sure to be fascinating as the wines develop over the coming years. Astute readers will note the slight name change here, which is the result of new regulations that require the use of the historic vineyard name, in this case Ginestra, or a proprietary name... Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
Richard Young
Wine Specialist Christie's
Very surprising and different style of Clerico
Very surprising and different style of Clerico
9.4Ludovic Anacleto
'07 vintage Serious, tight and on the austere side. Mouthfeel is striking. Tannins are MASSIVE, coating the entire mouth, letting a magnificent dark cherry emerging. I absolutely loved this wine. A keeper, give it ten years collaring as the tannins are quite present.
'07 vintage Serious, tight and on the austere side. Mouthfeel is striking. Tannins are MASSIVE, coating the entire mouth, letting a magnificent dark cherry emerging. I absolutely loved this wine. A keeper, give it ten years collaring as the tannins are quite present.
9.7Duane Mason
Needs time. No rush to drink.
Needs time. No rush to drink.
8.8Jeffrey Davies
This wine’s been shut down tight as a drum ever since I acquired it five or six years ago based on Antonio’s recommendation. But tonight, it finally started to strut its stuff and what fine, aromatically complex, stuff it is! Thank you., Antonio!
This wine’s been shut down tight as a drum ever since I acquired it five or six years ago based on Antonio’s recommendation. But tonight, it finally started to strut its stuff and what fine, aromatically complex, stuff it is! Thank you., Antonio!
Thijs Hendriks
Fresh, velvety, rich, roses, hazelnuts, delicious
Fresh, velvety, rich, roses, hazelnuts, delicious
9.7Ron Siegel
Drinking well that is consistent with my prior notes.
Drinking well that is consistent with my prior notes.
9.3Ron Siegel
This was singing tonight after giving it a little air as the change was dramatic where it started off with a ripeness & full body note that opened up to a more classically styled Barolo that was structured showing a perfumed nose of tart cherry, spice box with menthol, dried herbs, tar & rose petal. I have had this wine many times & tonight this was the best btl that I have had of this.
This was singing tonight after giving it a little air as the change was dramatic where it started off with a ripeness & full body note that opened up to a more classically styled Barolo that was structured showing a perfumed nose of tart cherry, spice box with menthol, dried herbs, tar & rose petal. I have had this wine many times & tonight this was the best btl that I have had of this.
9.5Ron Siegel
Still youthful that is classically styled & structured Barolo showing red cherry, leather, dried herbs, licorice, rose petal & tobacco.
Still youthful that is classically styled & structured Barolo showing red cherry, leather, dried herbs, licorice, rose petal & tobacco.
9.3Ron Siegel
Youthful & full bodied with good tannin structure showing ripe cherry, plum fruits, licorice, mineral, tar & violets
Youthful & full bodied with good tannin structure showing ripe cherry, plum fruits, licorice, mineral, tar & violets
9.3WARNING: DRINKING DISTILLED SPIRITS, BEER, COOLERS, WINE AND OTHER ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES MAY INCREASE CANCER RISK, AND, DURING PREGNANCY, CAN CAUSE BIRTH DEFECTS.