Château Simard Saint-Émilion Red Bordeaux Blend 2005

Ratings on Delectable

jerod peitsmeyer Delectable Pro

so hot

so hot

9.4

Geoff Troup Delectable Pro

Sales Eder Brothers, Cellar Fine Wines

Whoaaaaa '05 Bordeaux. '04 vintage was beautifully funky. Austere and difficult for some, but I loved it. This is much more complex. A little brett, dusty tannins, heavy spice, and a very dirty nose. Terrific now, but I would love to have 1 a year for the next 10 to see how it's doing.

Whoaaaaa '05 Bordeaux. '04 vintage was beautifully funky. Austere and difficult for some, but I loved it. This is much more complex. A little brett, dusty tannins, heavy spice, and a very dirty nose. Terrific now, but I would love to have 1 a year for the next 10 to see how it's doing.

9.3

Kyle Doucet-Walter Delectable Pro

Blackberries, meaty, leather, tobacco, licorice. Well intergrated tannins and a very welcome bitterness on the long finish.

Blackberries, meaty, leather, tobacco, licorice. Well intergrated tannins and a very welcome bitterness on the long finish.

8.7

garry post

We tried but this wine did not meet us halfway. Maybe it wasn't treated well at the grocery store or somewhere between the winery and our kitchen.

We tried but this wine did not meet us halfway. Maybe it wasn't treated well at the grocery store or somewhere between the winery and our kitchen.

8.8

Daniel Maquin

Black currant, red forest fruits, licorice, irony wet and heavy soil. The palate is well done with a strong acid backbone, some black currant on the sides, some nice velvetty touch on the sides. This is not very wide nor very powerful but it rolls in the mouth. The tannins are fully integrated now and leave room for a tanguy, fruity finish with a pinch of bitterness. This is simple and well done but I expected a bit more structure and power considering the vintage.

Black currant, red forest fruits, licorice, irony wet and heavy soil. The palate is well done with a strong acid backbone, some black currant on the sides, some nice velvetty touch on the sides. This is not very wide nor very powerful but it rolls in the mouth. The tannins are fully integrated now and leave room for a tanguy, fruity finish with a pinch of bitterness. This is simple and well done but I expected a bit more structure and power considering the vintage.

9.1

Michelle Hale

Absolutely delicious! If you can find it order it!

Absolutely delicious! If you can find it order it!

9.0

Robin Carbonneau

Very smooth, leaves, mineral

Very smooth, leaves, mineral

9.3

Thierry POUSSIN

2005 à Locmariaquer

2005 à Locmariaquer

9.1

Matt Miller

Sawdust and old chalkboard on the nose. Light and subtle with the first taste then builds through the middle that is bold, but without the fresh fruit notes from new world wines. The finish has a distinct minerality that accents the age of the wine.

Sawdust and old chalkboard on the nose. Light and subtle with the first taste then builds through the middle that is bold, but without the fresh fruit notes from new world wines. The finish has a distinct minerality that accents the age of the wine.

9.2

Sherwin Samson

Translucent burgundy, orange halo. Smells of earth, leather, and damp moss. Notes of black pepper seem to hit first followed by dark plum. Tannins are prominent, long finish. A hint of strawberry jam on the lips. This vintage was really enjoyable, especially with a French chanterelle risotto. It does not seem fully matured, personally I think another 5 years from now.

Translucent burgundy, orange halo. Smells of earth, leather, and damp moss. Notes of black pepper seem to hit first followed by dark plum. Tannins are prominent, long finish. A hint of strawberry jam on the lips. This vintage was really enjoyable, especially with a French chanterelle risotto. It does not seem fully matured, personally I think another 5 years from now.

8.5

Location

  • 600 Washington St.
    New York, NY 10014

  • Hours:
    Mon-Fri. 10-8
    Sat. 11-8
    Sun. Closed

WARNING: DRINKING DISTILLED SPIRITS, BEER, COOLERS, WINE AND OTHER ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES MAY INCREASE CANCER RISK, AND, DURING PREGNANCY, CAN CAUSE BIRTH DEFECTS.